asymmetry

Raw Abuse as Argument

0808

— 3 min read

A typical Substack conversation 

Protagonist A 

Responding to an earlier post ‘Is resisting ICE breaking the law?’ re Renee Good, and Alex Pretti…

https://physicsandfaith.org/is-resisting-ice-breaking-the-law/

“How many have been killed by your illegal pets? Thise two got themselves killed by deliberately inserting themselves into on going law enforcement activity.”

“{Your c* mother …f*** …sd@fff..}”

Response

Let’s set off on the right foot.
Abuse is not evidence. 

Really.

I don’t understand what you mean by

 “killed by your illegal pets? Thise two got themselves killed by deliberately inserting themselves into on going law enforcement activity.”

Pets: I have 3 cats. Not homicidal. Survived living with them for many, many years. So, to answer your question- 0.

I’ll assume you mean Renee Good and Alex Pretti.

So many loaded statements;

I mean - have you stopped beating your wife/son/mother/dog/sister/father?

Loaded means you are making claims like ‘deliberately’. A claim is not evidence, it needs evidence; it’s not a fact; it is testable.

Law enforcement: ICE cannot claim legal protection while committing an illegal act against the person from whom they’re demanding compliance. 

That’s not radical, it’s hornbook law. Fact…

ICE, by design and intent, dress to ‘kill’… pure cosplay, with live ammo; this is not law enforcement…you know that…

Victim blaming! At least you’re using multi syllable words, a step in the right direction.

You’re better than this. I just know it.

When a woman gets raped, it really is not very helpful or constructive to say it was her fault; quite apart from being incorrect…she wasn’t the one with the uncontrollable penis…

This is your first step on the way to leading an ethical life.

No Jesus, no church. Just the principle of reciprocity; just…

  • do unto others as you would have them do unto you…
  • before kicking a dog, ask yourself, ”would I be happy being the dog?”

How do you apply it here?
Well, you imagine yourself in Renee’s shoes on that day.

Ok?
Close your eyes.

Relax.

You’ve just dropped off your child and all of a sudden

…you’re surrounded by a number of large, aggressively driven SUVs screaming to a stop with no regard for traffic,

…spilling a pack of armed, masked thugs waving guns and other weapons...

Fuck! Me!..

Mexico City …come to visit an American school...

(see! Law enforcement is not the first goto…)

You slam on your brakes,

reverse to do a u turn; you’re being screamed at, conflicting instructions, stop, go, turn, leave;

…you carefully turn away from an agent approaching you, your executioner…

you smile to diffuse the situation; you don’t want him to feel bad, or shoot you…so, you say…

  • “it’s ok. I’m not mad at you”, 
  • and turn away from him. 

But he keeps stepping into your path, you apply maximum right hand lock and slowly pull away; you don’t want to hit him with your car…or him to shoot you…

fuck he has his gun out! 

Why? I’m not armed. I’m a mum, ffs.

Then you hear a bang, feel a tearing pain in your arm, then again; you hear a man say

“fucking bitch”;

an intense pain in your head…

In all of that how was your presence a clear and present danger to anyone, least of all the platoon of undisciplined, aggressive, masked, armed, & armoured, thugs? 

… with Pretti, even more absurd..

6, armed, un-holstered, agents dog pile one man, one holstered weapon, trying to protect, with his back to the dog pile… multiply executed, while face down on the ground... classic law enforcement…

..if you’re IDF…

See, simples,

walk in another’s shoes, for even a minute, and you will be a better human being.

And then you wasted 6 words, about 100 letters in silly, playground abuse. 

What.
Are you 5 years old?
If so, should you really be talking to strangers online?

Good luck.“​​​​​​​​​​​

Read more